August Board Meeting Quick NotesAugust 25, 2014
August 13, 2014
Mark Simmons, Wayne Lohman, Kim Collier, Candy Weaver, Bill Capstack, Dennis Polson, Randy Bigler, Richard Preston, Don Harwell, Dave Compton, Mike Peters. Steve Farrin was absent. Also present, Carolyn Wells, Karrin Murphy and Megan LeBlanc, MMA.
Recognizing barbeque as America’s cuisine, the mission of the Kansas City Barbeque Society is to celebrate, teach, preserve and promote barbeque as a culinary technique, sport and art form.
I accept my duties as a KCBS director to further the KCBS mission so that truth, justice and excellence in barbeque and the American way of life may be strengthened and preserved forever.
Minutes of July Meeting
Candy Weaver: I move to accept minutes of last meeting. 2ND LOHMAN. PASSED.
NOTE THAT AN ADDITION TO JULY FINANCIAL STATEMENTS WAS ADDED FOR AMERICAN CENTURY INVESTMENT ACCOUNT.
Kim Collier: I ask the BOD to accept the July financial reports. 2ND PRESTON. PASSED
NOTE THAT AMERICAN CENTURY INVESTMENT ACCOUNT HAS BEEN SETUP.
Mark Simmons: LOTS OF INTERACTION WITH COOKS, JUDGES, REPS AND ORGANIZERS FEELS LIKE THERE’S REALLY GOOD SPIRIT OUT THERE. COMMENDS BOARD AND BBQ FAMILY.
Karrin Murphy: Automatic Approval
REC’D DATES NAME CITY, STATE
Existing Contests 2014– In house Approval
7/21/2014 11/13-18/2014 World Food Championships- Las Vegas, NV
World Barbecue Championships
New Contests 2014 – In house Approval
7/11/2014 9/6-7/2014 Sky’s the Limit BBQ Classic Garden City, KS
7/8/2014 10/3-4/2014 Pigfest USA Hillard, OH
7/7/2014 10/18-19/2014 WinnaVegas Rib Master Classic Sloan, IA
Existing Contests 2015 – In house Approval
7/7/2014 2/21-22/2015 Smokin’ Hot BBQ San Juan San Juan, Puerto Rico
7/29/2014 3/13-14/2015 Don’t Be Cruel BBQ Duel Tupelo, MS
7/29/2014 4/10-11/2015 Cedar Fest BBQ Cedar Park, TX
7/21/2014 4/17-18/2015 Bynum Schools Best of the Basin Midland, TX
7/7/2014 5/1-2/2015 Smokin’ Hot BBQ Nassau Nassau Bahamas
7/21/2014 5/1-2/2015 The Whistlestop Festival & Rocket Huntsville, AL
7/29/2014 5/1-2/2015 Naptown barBAYq Contest and Annapolis, MD
7/22/2014 5/1-2/2015 Brews, Blues & Bar-B-Q Cookoff Lansing, KS
8/7/2014 5/1-2/2015 Apple Blossom BBQ Contest St. Joseph, MO
7/14/2014 5/2-3/2015 Ridgefield Gone Country BBQ Festival Ridgefield, CT
7/22/2014 5/22-23/2015 Best Dam Barbecue Boulder City, NV
7/30/2014 5/22-23/2015 Red, White and BBQ (Day1) Westmont, IL
7/30/2014 5/23-24/2015 Red, White and BBQ (Day2) Westmont, IL
7/31/2014 6/19-20/2015 Barbourville BBQ Cook-Off & Festival Barbourville, KY
7/7/2014 6/26-27/2015 3rd Annual Willard Freedom Willard, MO
Feast BBQ Cook-Off
8/4/2014 6/26-27/2015 3rd Annual Ribtock MBA BBQ Festival Omaha, NE
New Contests 2015 – In house Approval
8/1/2014 4/24-25/2015 Morris Twister Days BBQ Competition Morris, OK
7/21/2014 5/29-30/2015 Horse Town Brew n Que Festival Norco, CA
7/29/2014 7/10-11/2015 Chillin & Grillin in the Glades Wise, VA
7/8/2014 5/8-9/2015 Wheatstock Grill-Off Abilene, KS
Conflict: Lawrence, KS -115 miles (contests did not co-exist in 2014)
ONLY 1 TEAM WAS AT BOTH CONTESTS THIS YEAR. KIM STATED NO PROBLEM WITH SANCTIONING BOTH EVENTS.
WEAVER MOVES TO APPROVE THE ABILENE, KS EVENT. 2ND POLSON. PASSED.
Sanctioning Committee Report
Randy Bigler: No report
MMA Marketing Report -- Megan LeBlanc
JUST COMPLETED MARKETING PACKAGE WITH FOODSAVER AND SIGNED CONTRACT.
● Total July Sales: $2,681.31
● 61 - Birthday redemption YTD
● 38 – Cookbooks YTD
• Advertising sold for July: $1,540
● 549 members have opted in to receive Birthday emails YTD
100KCBS Meals Mission
• 21 out of 55 events completed
• 26,567 meals donated so far (27% of completion within 92 days)
• Continual PR/Social Media Updates
30,000+ MEALS SERVED. ON TRACK TO REACH 100K. MISSING SOME EVENTS’ PAPERWORK.
• 21 Local events complete
• 1 Regional events complete
• Successfully changed the Rockford, IL Regional location to Madison, WI with just a few hurdles
• Continual PR/Social Media Updates - Picked up by 165 media outlets that has so far reached 13,281,686 impressions since launch
• Utilized KCBS Marketing funds to successfully secure FB ads, 2 radio remotes
• Sent eBlast reminder that Bentonville Judges registration will begin Aug 6th
• On-going coordination and logistics for 2014 Sam's Tour
Great American Cookout Tour
• 11 festivals and 25 retail stops completed
• Continual PR/Social Media Updates
• On-going coordination and logistics for GAC
Reser’s America’s Best Potato Salad Challenge
• 4 out of the 5 competitions completed
• Next stop August 8th Ribs, Pigs & Watermelons in Huntington State Beach, CA
BBQ Guru Challenge
• 5 out of the 10 competitions completed
• Next stop August 8th Ribs, Pigs & Watermelons in Huntington State Beach, CA
PR – Courtney
• Social Media, using KCBS, and GAC Facebook and Twitter pages to promote KCBS-related events/promotion
• GAC: 1% increase in Twitter Followers (4,784 ) / 1% increase in FB Likes (24,371)
• KCBS: 1% increase in Twitter Followers (6,897) / 1% increase in FB Likes (28,518)
• Updated News section of KCBS website as necessary (Region 3 preview article, Sam’s Nat’l event results)
• Bullsheet Content – Sam’s, GAC, Reser's, BBQ Guru, McCormick Grill Mates KCBS Match Up
• Event Photos and recap addition to the website slated to be complete on August 15. TO BE DONE BY FRIDAY. KARRIN WILL BE TRAINED HOW TO DO THIS.
LOHMAN: ANY MEDIA ATTENTION FROM 100K MISSION OR OTHER KCBS ACTIVITIES? LeBLANC: YES AND WILL SHARE THAT.
WEAVER: HAS THE LIST PROVIDED OF BAD LINKS ON THE WEB SITE, BEEN REPAIRED? LeBLANC: KARRIN IS WORKING ON THAT.
Wayne Lohman: The KCBS International Team has been busy this summer preparing for their third trip to Europe in September. Our first stop will be a cooking/judging class in Heinsberg, Germany at Otto Gourmet Company, a high end meat importer. This location has been our most successful teaching event in Center Europe as we have held this class for the past 3 years with an average of 30 cooking teams and 24 CBJ’s.
The following week we travel to Diksmuide, Belgium for the Lowlands BBQ Championship. This event recognizes the 100 year battle between the Belgium and French troops resisting the advancing German troops. We are very pleased that Carolyn Wells will be attending this celebration, CBJ class and our 2nd sanctioned Belgium Contest. We are expecting 40 competing teams with an estimated public attendance of 40,000 during the weekend.
The Lohmans will stay an extra week to rep our first German contest in Nordrheim Westfalen. This contest is close to Otto Gourmet in Heinsberg, so we expect to have 100% certified judges. To date, we have 13 teams signed up. This contest organizer is Roman Schellartz, director of a very successful Octoberfest event in the area so we expect this contest to grow in the future.
One of the secondary benefits to our International growth has
been the development of a working relationship with a major grill manufacturer who has been a prominent sponsor for our new International Contests. We have taught our cooking classes in their grilling academies and certified their teaching chefs in the UK, Scandinavia and Italy. This relationship has carried over to the World Food Championship where they have agreed to supply the International Teams with cooking equipment and supplies while sponsoring the International Village at this event.
Since the July report we have scheduled two new sanctioned contests for 2015. Our first Australian Contest is in Melbourne on Feb. 7 & 8, at Queen Victoria Market. Melbourne is known as the food city in Australia. Our newest contest was scheduled this week for Brugg, Switzerland for the weekend of May 2-3. At both of these locations we will teach our cooking/judging classes with a sanctioned contest to follow. The organizer of the Melbourne contest has asked that we have a separate class for the local butcher shops in the Queen Victoria Market who are not familiar with US cuts of meat.
CBJ Committee Report:
Don Harwell: Tuesday July 29th the CBJ Committee held its monthly meeting.
Much of the meeting was discussion on Judges scoring different than being taught from the present CBJ training. Example of a judge’s statement was heard: “I score down on the chicken box if it does not have white meat.” Or “If the brisket box does not have burnt ends it will get a lower score from me”. The fact is a judge must not score down because of what is not there!
All the committee members agree we must continue to educate judges after their CBJ class.
• We are about to kick off the “CBJs Continuing Education Program” which will aid judges on changes and just keeping a CBJ refreshed with judging within KCBS. FYI, after completing this yearly program a CBJ will receive a lapel pin (rocker) to display their achievement.
• Articles on the KCBS WEB and Bullsheet are a must we all agree, and committee member Ed Hartman has taken the task to working on these.
• As we all know we play a recording at each judges meeting, this needs to be reviewed for updates yearly.
• Handouts were discussed and will continue to be reviewed
Discussion also was held on: How often can a judge cook with a team before he/she cannot judge at a contest at which the cook team is competing in. The CBJ committee will continue discussion on this issue and report back to the BOD next month. This discussion also turned to family members of the cook team judging and when they can judge / table captain again more thoughts will be provided to the BOD from the committee on this.
A new revision of the 2014 CBJ Class Organizer’s Guide is available with new edits and new fees outlined. The committee believes that there needs to also be a Certified Table Captain’s (CTC) Class Organizer’s Guide. This guide is being created and patterned after the CBJ Class guide.
A critique of the CBJ class and instructor has been created and tested. Each class will begin using these to get feedback of the classes. Thanks Carol Bigler. THANKS TO ED HARTMAN ON HIS EFFORTS RELATING TO CONTINUING CBJ EDUCATION AND ARTICLES IN THE BULLSHEET ON JUDGING.
Note: New colors being added to the CBJ shirt. Keep checking KCBS.us for the new colors.
The next CBJ committee meeting is scheduled for August the 26th, 2014.
Kim Collier: Motion to accept new reps and reps in training after discussion in closed session.
KCBS Score Committee/Technology Committee
Kim Collier: Nothing to report
PETERS: QUESTION ON KCBSCORE, IS UPCOMING VERSION GOING TO GIVE US THE ABILITY FOR JUDGES TO SIGN UP ON LINE AT CONTESTS?
COLLIER: YES. WILL THERE BE A WAY TO GIVE THE JUDGES’ AVERAGE PER TABLE? COLLIER: THIS WILL HAPPEN THROUGH STATISTICS GROUP. NOT RIGHT NOW. DISCUSSION ON HOW TO ‘BALANCE’ A TABLE AND JUDGE SCORING HISTORY.
HARWELL: DISAGREES WITH THIS. AVERAGING OF JUDGES ACROSS A CONTEST, I WANT TO SEE THAT. IF A JUDGE IS CONSTANTLY LOW OR HIGH EVERY TIME, THAT NEEDS TO BE KNOWN. WHAT’S THE TIMELINE ON DOING THIS?
COLLIER: 1ST ANNIVERSARY OF KCBSCORE JUST PAST. JUDGE SIGN UP DONE END OF SEPTEMBER. TRACKING JUDGES WE’LL BE WORKING WITH BBQSCORECARD.COM ON THIS. DISCUSSION OF CONTACT IN CLOSED SESSION.
HARWELL: LET BOARD TEST ONLINE JUDGING SIGN UP BEFORE RELEASE. COLLIER: YES.
WEAVER: SCOPE OF JUDGES ONLINE SIGNUP. KCBS WILL NOT BE SELECTING JUDGES FOR CONTEST, CORRECT? COLLER: THAT’S RIGHT. DESCRIBED PROPOSED FLOW, CONTESTS HAVE CONTROL OVER JUDGES USED. TOOL FOR ORGANIZERS TO HELP GET JUDGES. PETERS: WAY TO INCREASE JUDGE ACCOUNTABILITY TO GET THEM TO SHOW UP TO JUDGE? COLLIER: ORGANIZER WILL HAVE TRAIL OF JUDGES CONFIRMED AND THEN NO-SHOW.
WEAVER: WHERE ARE WE ON COOKS PAMPLET? COLLIER SENT FARRIN WORD DOC AND WEAVER EDITS TO COMMITTEE. IN PROGRESS BOARD WILL REVIEW BEFORE PRINTING.
CAPSTACK: ON JUDGE SIGNUP, WILL IT BE CLEAR ON WEB SITE? COLLIER: YES.
CAPSTACK: WHEN DOES IT CUT OFF? COLLIER: WHEN ORGANIZER SAYS THEY HAVE THEIR JUDGES.
CAPSTACK: USE FOR MULTIPLE CONTESTS? COLLIER: ALL CBJ INFO WILL BE THERE FOR ORGANIZER PLUS EXPERIENCE.
HARWELL: I HAVE MORE QUESTIONS, PLEASE SEND ME REQUIREMENTS E-MAIL SO I DON’T TAKE UP BOARD TIME, I SEE HOLES IN THIS. COLLIER: OKAY
COMPTON: WAY FOR ORGANIZER’S TO SEND CBJ NUMBERS AND KCBS COULD SET UP THE TABLES WITH STATISTICAL EVENNESS. COLLIER: THIS COULD POSSIBLY HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE.
HARWELL: MAKE SURE TO ASK HOW MANY JUDGED THIS YEAR. POLSON: FOR MIKE, YOU’RE IN COLORADO, RIGHT? PETERS: YES. POLSON: YOU SHOULD VISIT WITH ROCKY MOUNTAIN BBQ ASSOCIATION ABOUT HOW THEY DO IT.
HARWELL: WHY DON’T WE JUST SUBCONTRACT WITH RMBBQA INSTEAD OF BUILDING OUR OWN? THEY’VE GOT A REALLY NICE SYSTEM, WHY ARE WE STARTING FRESH? POLSON: THEY CHARGE THE ORGANIZER FOR USING THIS. HARWELL: THEY MAY CHARGE US A LESSER FEE. COLLIER: WE’RE AREN’T CHARGING ORGANIZERS AT ALL. SIMMONS: IT’S A VALUE ADDED TOOL. WEAVER: A COMMUNICATIONS TOOL. COLLIER: COST IS NOTHING, EASIER TO DO THIS IN-HOUSE, WE CAN GIVE BENEFIT BACK TO ORGANIZERS. HARWELL: I THINK YOU MAY BE MINIMIZING THIS.
Mike Peters: We are looking at these meetings for the upcoming banquet.
> Rules Meeting
> Organizers Meeting
> Marketing Meeting
> Rep Meeting
> CBJ/TC Best Practices/Standards
> Rub/Sauce bringing to market
> Butcher class
> How to get sponsorships
> How to become a KCBS Rep
> BOD open forum for Q/A
> Judge Tracking - how will KCBS use this data at contests?
>CPR safety class
Any other suggestions before we finalize the weekend?
FOOD SAFETY & HANDLING/SERVSAFESERV.
PETERS: BUILDING MORE MEETINGS FOR MORE INTERESTING THINGS TO DO THAN WHAT WE’VE DONE IN THE PAST.
SAMPLING FOOD AND SEEING ROOMS AT 2015 HOTEL THIS SUNDAY.
SIMMONS: BACKYARD? BIGLER: NOT FOR THIS MEETING IF THAT CHANGES I’LL LET YOU KNOW.
SIMMONS: SOMETHING THAT COULD APPEAL TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC?
WEAVER: BBQ BOOT CAMP.
SIMMONS: COMBINING CBJ AND COOKING CLASS.
WEAVER: SEE HOW INTERNATIONAL CBJ/COOKING CLASSES ARE DONE. HARWELL: BETTER NOT BE DIFFERENT. LOHMAN: THEY ARE. CAPSTACK: HOLD THIS FOR 30TH.
HARWELL: ONE OF MY GOALS FOR ALL CBJ CLASSES IN NORTH AMERICA TO BE THE SAME EVERYWHERE. WEAVER: DIDN’T BRING THAT UP TO SHAKE UP CBJ CLASS, ONLY TO SUGGEST HOW TO REACH PEOPLE WHO DON’T KNOW ABOUT BBQ COMPETITION OTHER THAN WHAT THEY SEE ON TV.
HARWELL: MAYBE WE SHOULD JUST HAVE MIKE DO SOMETHING MORE WITH THE TRAILER, COOK AND TALK ABOUT KCBS. LOHMAN: APPRECIATE COMMENTS AND CONCERNS REGARDING INTERNATIONAL CBJ CLASSES, CONTENT WE TEACH IS PRIMARILY THE SAME, WE JUST GO INTO DEPTH MORE BECAUSE OF THE CULTURES AREN’T FAMILIAR WITH THE BBQ PROCESS. HAPPY TO TALK TO YOU, DON, AND ADDRESS CONCERNS.
PETERS: BE NEAT FOR THE 30TH TO INVITE ALL PAST ToY WINNERS TO HAVE A COMPETITION. SET UP CONSISTENT JUDGES AND TIE THIS IN WITH A COOKING CLASS. WELLS: THAT’S A FABULOUS IDEA! HARWELL: INVITE CHARTER MEMBERS TO JUDGE THIS AS AN HONOR TO THEM.
We are looking at travel costs before we make a suggestion for 2017 banquet location.
Monthly Committee Meeting July 17, 2014 (Next meeting August 21, 2014)
Members on Conference Call: Richard Preston, Chair, Dennis Polston, Vice Chair, Ernie Hiers, Recorder, Ralph Weller, Dave Amend, Mark Simmons, President, Bill Shiflett, Ardie Lauxman, Carolyn Wells, Executive Director. Absent: Ryan McBreen, Sammye Phelps, Membership Services
GOALS FOR 2014
• Increase membership to 20,000 (currently 19,073)
• Increase lifetime membership to 600 (currently 529)
• Expand membership services
• Target date mid August, 2014
KCBS Feeding 100,000 Initiatives
• 22,335 meals served (this does not include this weekend)
• Looking into more advertisement on this program
Certified BBQ Pitmaster Program (CBP) – DIFFERENT LEVELS – WILL BRING BACK TO THE BOARD IN SEPTEMBER
• Logo – Richard, Program will be call KCBS Pitmaster
• Application form – Filing for second extension on trademark, no artwork was found
• Committee members should submit ideas for the program levels via the KCBS email group – Hiers will compile documents and send draft back out to committee members. Submissions should be by July 27th.
• Carolyn suggested that the levels should be something like bronze, silver, gold, and platinum
Membership Discount Update
• Restaurant Finder feature is complete and was planned to go live on July 15, with a E-blast about the feature being sent out afterwards. The release has been delayed for a few weeks.
Lifetime Member – (Submitted by Dennis Polston) – This will be discussed next meeting
The older members of KCBS do not see the advantage of a Life Membership but would still like to be a Life Member. There might be many reasons why they are not becoming Life Members -- money, health, age, cutting out driving long distances to contests, family, etc.
This is what I was thinking:
A member 65 years old or older (is could be 60 or whatever we come up with) that has paid their dues 5 CONSECUTIVE years be added together and subtract that amount from a Life Membership.
Example: A person is now 70 and they have paid 5 years of consecutive dues (single 175.00) (family 250.00), subtract that from a Life Membership they would now owe (single 175.00) (family 250.00).
Now a problem we might have is those Life Members that fit into this situation that have already become Life Members. Do we do a refund if asked?
We have a few members that have been longtime members, 20 consecutive years plus. Should we do something for them? Most I think would fit in the above example. But a parent or grandparent might have bought a child membership before we came up with a Life Membership. That person could be in their 30, 40, 50's.
MEMBERSHIP NUMBERS FOR JUNE, 2014 (provided by Sammye Phelps)
• Total Members 19,318
• New Members 591
• Renewed Members 1,137
• Non-Renewals 657
o Signed via Website 276 (31 families)
o New Members (Judging Classes) 287
o Lifetime Members 563
o Number of International Members 587
o Number of Countries 24
Dennis Polson: The Nominations article is in the August issue of the Bullsheet. TWO POTENTIAL CANDIDATES HAVE THEIR NAME IN THE HAT TO RUN.
Candy Weaver: The Education/Communications Committee met briefly on July 15, 2014. Attending were Dennis Polson, Mike McDearman, Ralph Williams, Candy Weaver, Carolyn Wells and Mark Simmons.
Dennis discussed the lottery draw for backyard Shadetree competitors at the Jack.
Continuing efforts on digital Bullsheet.
Bluetoad announced translation modules for article view. Languages included are French, German, Portugese, Spanish and traditional Chinese. Board did approve on July 9, the conversion of the August issue. Candy will include more detailed instructions on expanding screen size, clicking on URL addresses to go straight to advertiser web sites and e-mail addresses to open an e-mail window. Compile a list of questions for advertisers regarding the digital Bullsheet.
Currently digital Bullsheet is open for anyone to view if you have the link, which is available in KCBS News. Older issues in PDF format are stored under member download section. Do we want to password protect the Bullsheet? Is there not a benefit to using this as a draw to potential members? Explore making part of the Bullsheet open with the rest password protected for members (with a link to join up). MORE POSITIVE RESPONSES TO THIS THAN NEGATIVE.
Discussed the need to change advertising prices for commercial advertisers (not organizers). Will look at advertising rates of comparable publications.
Web site issues. Compiling list of broken links. If you find any, please pass them along. With Kids' Que list update, 3 broken contest links found for September. Those have been fixed. Mike McDearman discussed 4H program in Tennessee that he's doing.
Carolyn discussed computer and phone issues at the office the week of July 7th.
The August Bullsheet was converted to and live on August 4th. From August 4 to the morning of the 8th, there have been 617 unique visits with an average time spent reading 10 minutes.
Next meeting is August 19th.
SIMMONS: TARGET FOR IMPLEMENTING DIGITAL BULLSHEET.
WEAVER: WORK ON HOW TO MOVE FOCUS TO GOING DIGITAL ON THE BULLSHEET. ESTABLISH A DATE CERTAIN TO GO DIGITAL OR PAY FOR EXTRA FOR PAPER VERSION.
Strategic Planning Committee
Our committee met twice since our last board meeting in July
Our current objectives include:
• KCBS Foundation 501(c)(3)
• Executive Director Succession Planning
• Expanding the Diversity of KCBS Events
• Permanent Home for KCBS
• Document the History of KCBS
KCBS Foundation 501(c)(3) Status:
• The application has been delivered to our legal firm for submission to the IRS
HARWELL: QUESTION REGARDING FUNDS FROM THE 501(C)(4) AND IMPACT OF (C)(3) APPLICATION. CAPSTACK: CAROLYN HAS WORKED WITH LAWYERS FOR SOME MONTHS NOW.
WELLS: COMPLETE CONFIDENCE IN ATTORNEYS LOOKING OUT FOR OUR STATUS. HARWELL: CONFIDENCE IN OUR ATTORNEYS TOO.
SIMMONS: IS ALL PAPERWORK SENT OFF? WELLS: IN ATTORNEYS’ HANDS. SIMMONS: THIS IS GOING TO BE A SEPARATE ENTITY FROM KCBS. CAPSTACK: KCBS FOUNDATION ONLY.
Executive Director Succession Planning:
• On-going discussions with emphasis towards examining the job requirements and compensation package to be presented to the board in the near future
Expanding the Diversity of KCBS Events:
• On-going discussions
• Wayne Lohman will discuss a great opportunity for us to consider. LOHMAN: LATE LAST WEEK, I WAS CONTACTED BY A CBJ/ORGANIZER WHO WAS INTERESTED IN KCBS JUDGING FOR OTHER FOOD GROUPS. OYSTER CONTEST AT THE HANGOUT AT THE WHARF (GULF SHORES, MS EST. DATE 11/8). ASKED WAYNE TO DO THE ACTUAL RUNNING OF THE CONTEST. REPLACE TENDERNESS WITH CREATIVITY. IT’LL BE PROFESSIONAL CHEFS COMPETING. BIGLER: FOOLISH NOT TO DO THIS! WEAVER: I WANT TO JUDGE! HARWELL: HOW ARE THEY DOING JUDGING AND HOW WOULD WE TRAIN JUDGES?
LOHMAN: JUDGES ARE CHOSEN, THEY ARE PROFESSIONAL CHEFS ALSO.
COLLIER: DID A LICENSED CONTEST SIMILAR TO THAT, WILL SHARE INFORMATION. SIMMONS: ANY REASON NOT TO PURSUE? COMPTON: NO REASON NOT TO.
WEAVER: CAROLYN, MIKE MCCLOUD AND I DID SOMETHING FOR STAR CHEFS, PLATED NOT BOXED. ASK CAROLYN. LOHMAN: WELCOME ALL SUGGESTIONS.
Permanent Home for KCBS:
• On-going discussions
Document the History of KCBS:
• On-going discussions
Our committee was previously tasked with developing/documenting committee descriptions. That was completed. At our BOD meeting in June 2014 the Executive Committee was given the responsibility of negotiating the MMA contract renewal. There is no record of this committee being created. The recommended verbiage below is submitted for your approval:
HARWELL: THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE IS THE EXECUTIVES ON THE BOARD, THAT’S WHAT IT ALWAYS IS. CAPSTACK: JUST FORMALIZING THIS. HARWELL: YOU SHOULD READ THE BYLAWS. CAPSTACK: IT’S NOT CALLED THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE IN THE BYLAWS.
I make a motion to DEFINE:
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE: Shall be comprised of the President, Vice-President, Treasurer, Secretary and the Executive Director. The committee shall be responsible for, but not limited to, negotiating contracts and other oversight actions as deemed necessary. 2ND COMPTON.
HARWELL: POINT OF ORDER – READ THE MOTION PLEASE. PLEASE READ LAST PART AGAIN. CONTRACTS ARE STILL APPROVED BY THE BOARD, CORRECT? SIMMONS: YES.
POLSON: ANY OTHER POTENTIAL CANDIDATES FOR REPLACING MMA? NO. COMPTON: CLOSED SESSION? SIMMONS: PROBABLY SO BUT IT’S BEEN ANSWERED.
Philanthropy Committee Report
Dave Compton: Our committee has been working on revamping the wording of the Gary Wells Sportsmanship and the Carolyn Wells Ambassador Awards. Nothing has really changed in the Awards themselves, mainly housekeeping issues. One of the biggest changes would be the way that nominations are sent in to KCBS. Right now they can be sent by mail to the office or by e-mail to any one of three people. This can lead to confusion and lost or misplaced information. I think that we should set up a dedicated e-mail address for these awards such as: firstname.lastname@example.org. That way we would have a permanent place to send these that wouldn't change if the office staff or the committee chair should change. Also, we would add language on who can nominate which persons for an award to say that they can't nominate themselves or a close family member.
Here are the changes in the following attachments:
Gary Wells KCBS Sportsman Award Criteria
WHAT: The recipient of the Gary Wells KCBS Sportsmanship Award will be one who exhibits exceptional qualities of a barbeque sportsman. This award would go is given to a KCBS member who displays a high level of observance of the rules, fairness, generosity, and good character. The recipient of the Gary Wells KCBS Sportsmanship award would exhibits these qualities on a regular basis and has shown a particularly exceptional example(s) of good sportsmanship at one or more KCBS barbeque contests.
WHO: Any member of KCBS may nominate a fellow member who is in good standing for this award and is not limited to cooks, judges, representatives, etc. A KCBS member cannot nominate him or herself OR A CLOSE FAMILY MEMBER. KCBS members serving on the board are not eligible for this award during the time of selection.
WHERE: The Gary Wells Sportsmanship Award will be announced and / or presented to the recipient at the annual KCBS banquet.
WHEN: The nomination for the Gary Wells KCBS Sportsmanship award must be emailed to the KCBS office and received no later than noon of December 1st of the year prior to the banquet. Call for award nominations will be posted on the website and printed In the Bullsheet from November 1st – November 30th for the year prior to the banquet.
HOW: A written email nomination must be made in the form of a letter that states the reasons for nomination along with examples of how the nominee has promoted KCBS as an organization to the general public.
The nomination letter will be read at the banquet prior to presentation of the award, with limited editing allowed by the award committee and /or board of directors and upon approval of the board of directors. The author of the letter and /or name of the person making the nomination is always kept confidential.
The award nomination committee will review all letters submitted and in the case of six or more letters, the Awards Committee will choose the top five letters to be reviewed by the board of directors. The board of directors will choose by way of voting and discussion, the recipient or in the event of a tie, recipients of the award no later than the December board meeting. The Board of Directors reserves the right to not make an award. All decisions by the Board of Directors are final.
Mail Nominations to: Email Nominations to either: (I would suggest identifying a single point of contact so there is no confusion, lost materials, etc.)
Carolyn Wells KCBS Ambassador Award Criteria
WHAT: The recipient of the Carolyn Wells KCBS Ambassador Award will be one who exhibits exceptional qualities of a KCBS ambassador. This award would go to a KCBS member who displays a high level of good character as well as especially promoting KCBS as an organization to the general public.
WHO: Any member of KCBS may nominate a fellow member who is in good standing for this award and is not limited to cooks, judges, representatives, etc. A KCBS member cannot nominate him or herself or a close family member. KCBS members serving on the board are not eligible for this award during the time of selection.
WHERE: The Carolyn Wells Ambassador Award will be announced and /or presented to the recipient at the annual KCBS banquet.
WHEN: The nomination for the Carolyn Wells Ambassador award must be emailed to the KCBS office and received no later than noon of December 1st of the year prior to the banquet.
Call for award nominations will be posted on the website and printed In the Bullsheet from November 1st – November 30th for the year prior to the banquet.
HOW: A written email nomination must be made in the form of a letter that states the reasons for nomination along with examples of how the nominee has promoted KCBS as an organization to the general public. The nomination letter will be read at the banquet prior to presentation of the award, with limited editing allowed by the award committee and /or board of directors and upon approval of the board of directors. The author of the letter and /or name of the person making the nomination is always kept confidential.
The award nomination committee will review all letters submitted and in the case of six or more letters, the committee will choose the top five letters to be reviewed by the board of directors.
The board of directors will choose by way of voting and discussion, the recipient or in the event of a tie, recipients of the award no later than the December board meeting.
Mail Nominations to: Email Nominations to either:
LIKE TO GET A DEDICATED E-MAIL ADDRESS FOR THIS: WELLSAWARDS@KCBS.US.
I MOVE THAT WE CHANGE THE WORDING OF THE GARY WELLS SPORTSMANSHIP AWARD AND CAROLYN WELLS AMBASSADOR AWARD FOR CRITERIA CHANGE. 2ND HARWELL
SIMMONS: WHEN ARE WELLS AWARDS ANNOUNCED? HARWELL: WOULD LIKE TO 2ND THIS MOTION. WELLS: RUN IN NOVEMBER? COMPTON: RAYE WAS WORKING TOWARDS SEPTEMBER. NEED TO GET IT OUT THERE AS SOON AS WE CAN. WELLS: CAN WE MAKE IT OCTOBER? COMPTON: YES.
I MOVE THAT WE CHANGE THE WORDING OF THE GARY WELLS SPORTSMANSHIP AWARD AND CAROLYN WELLS AMBASSADOR AWARD FOR CRITERIA CHANGE. 2ND HARWELL. PASSED.
Also, I am asking the Board's permission to start building an electronic application for the Grants in Aid program. If it's okay we should have a demonstration ready within two months.
WELLS: ALL GRANTS IN AID APPLICATIONS HAVE BEEN MAILED. COMPTON: TECH COMMITTEE PLEASE SENT UP E-MAIL ADDRESS.
Regional Representation Committee
Wayne Lohman: As requested by the Board in the June meeting, the following attachments are the findings that the Committee collected in our study of Regional Representative Directors. The Committee did not reach a conclusion or recommendation to the Board:
Attachment A is A MAP OF the Committees recommendation of 6 voting regions. This breakdown of voting regions were based on the requirements that the States be contiguous where possible and that the regions have the smallest voting variance as possible. These 6 regions have less than a 5% voting variance between the region with the fewest voting members and the region with the most voting members. SIMMONS: VOTING NUMBERS FROM MOST RECENT ELECTION.
At each year’s annual election, two regional directors and two at large directors would be elected to the Board. If a Director is unable to full fill his term commitment, the "unfinished term" would be based on whether the Director was from a particular region or an "at large" Director.
The Committee recommends that the membership votes on all Directors so that the total votes per region are similar to each region.
Attachment B lists the Pros and Cons of KCBS having Regional Representative Directors. This list was compiled by a previous Board when studying this issue. FROM PREVIOUS BOARD, STILL VALID TODAY. LOTS OF WORK TO BE DONE TO GET THIS TO THE MEMBERSHIP.
If the Board decides that they want the membership to vote on this issue then the details of the election would have to be worked out by the committee. Details that need to be addressed are election procedures, BullSheet notice and Bylaw changes.
CAPSTACK: BASING THIS ON VOTERS IN THE LAST ELECTION? WEST REGION IS 1.3 MILLION SQUARE MILES. 5 REGIONS REPRESENTED ON BOARD NOW. WHAT DOES REGIONALIZATION DO FOR US SINCE MOST REGIONS ARE REPRESENTED WITHOUT THIS.
HARWELL: OPPORTUNITY FOR SOMEONE TO RUN FROM A SPECIFIC REGION WHERE THEY ARE KNOWN TO BE VOTED TO THE BOARD. MAP SHOULDN’T BE SET IN STONE, ADJUST AS MEMBERSHIP CHANGES. PEOPLE WILL VOTE WHEN THEY KNOW SOMEONE. MEMBERS NEED TO VOTE ON THIS. CAPSTACK: COMMITTEE STILL HASN’T REACHED A CONCLUSION TO BRING ANYTHING TO THE MEMBERS FOR A VOTE. WHAT DOES PARAGRAPH 4 ABOVE MEAN? WHAT DOES THIS LOOK LIKE SO THE MEMBERS CAN VOTE ON IT?
HARWELL: BOARD VOTED FOR COMMITTEE TO CONTINUE EXAMINING THIS. DON’T HAVE ALL THE ANSWERS
LOHMAN: NEED DIRECTION FROM THE BOARD. THIS IS GOING TO TAKE A LOT OF TIME.
COLLIER: LAST MEETING TO TAKE IT BACK TO THE MEMBERS FOR THE BOARD TO PUSH THIS FORWARD. SIMMONS: CANDY, DO YOU HAVE THIS?
WEAVER: NOT THIS MONTH BUT EARLIER AND MY RECOLLECTION WAS THAT THE BOARD VOTED FOR THE COMMITTEE TO CONTINUE EFFORTS.
SIMMONS: THAT IS MY RECOLLECTION AS WELL. LOHMAN: IT WAS JUNE. CAPSTACK: WHAT’S TIMETABLE?
LOHMAN: MEMBERS NEED TO LOOK AT PROS AND CONS OF THIS. THERE’S AN EDUCATION PROCESS HERE.
HARWELL: CHANGES TO BYLAWS HAVE TO BE PUBLISHED A MONTH IN ADVANCE BEFORE THE VOTE.
SIMMONS: 1ST DOES THE BOARD WANT TO PRESENT THIS TO THE MEMBERSHIP? Y/N THEN, EXPOSE TO THE MEMBERSHIP. AFTER APPROVED IN JANUARY THEN THE NEXT JANUARY VOTE ON CHANGES TO BYLAWS, THEN IMPLEMENTATION.
LOHMAN: NOT 2016. SIMMONS: AT THE EARLIEST.
WEAVER: ARE WE TIED TO A JANUARY VOTE. SIMMONS: NORMAL BYLAW CHANGES ARE DONE AT ANNUAL MEETINGS. MY THOUGHT IS THAT DETAILS WOULD BE WORKED OUT BY NEXT YEAR’S BOARD.
HARWELL: THIS ISN’T BASEBALL, WE’VE VOTED TWICE AND MEMBERS HAVE SAID THEY WANT THIS. ARE WE AFRAID TO PUT THIS UP TO MEMBER VOTE?
SIMMONS: PREVIOUS VOTES BEGAN WITH 2 WORDS “NON BINDING” THEY DON’T COUNT.
HARWELL: WE’VE NEVER GIVEN MEMBERS A BYLAW CHANGE FOR REGIONAL REPRESENTATION.
LOHMAN: CHALLENGE TO EDUCATE THE MEMBERSHIP ON THIS. AT CURSORY GLANCE, THE ANSWERS YES. LESS THAN 20% VOTE. LET’S GET AS MUCH INFORMATION OUT THERE.
WEAVER: PUBLISH IN THE BULLSHEET AND ASK FOR MEMBER FEEDBACK? MINUTES AREN’T IN THE BULLSHEET ANYMORE. DO OUR MEMBERS A SERVICE AND LET THEM KNOW WHAT WE’RE GOING THROUGH TO DO THIS.
PETERS: E-BLAST TOO.
COMPTON: E-BLAST IS THE BEST DEAL. THE 3RD PARAGRAPH ABOVE NEEDS TO BE CLARIFIED. LOHMAN: WHOLE PROCESS HAS NOT BEEN THOUGHT THROUGH.
HARWELL: NONE OF US WANT TO SPEND 20-30 HOURS FOR THE BOARD TO SAY WE DON’T WANT TO DO THIS. CAPSTACK: IF BOARD SAYS YES, ANYTHING THAT GOES OUT TO THE MEMBERSHIP NEEDS TO BE SEEN BY THE BOARD FIRST.
LOHMAN: I WANT SOMETHING CLEAR CUT TO PROCEED ON THIS.
SIMMONS: PRO/CONS CAN BE IMPROVED ON. NEXT MEETING APPROVE THIS AND IT GO INTO THE BULLSHEET.
WEAVER: KICKING CAN DOWN THE ROAD ONE MORE MONTH. DEADLINE IS OCT. 15, PRO/CONS FOR E-BLAST. LOOK AT COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD AND SEE WHICH SEATS ARE OPEN FOR SURE.
SIMMONS: WHAT SEATS ARE UP NEXT YEAR?
WEAVER: I KNOW – MY SEAT IS THE NEXT OPEN SEAT IN 2016. OTHER CANDIDATES CAN RUN FOR RE-ELECTION.
PETERS: WOULD IT TAKE A BYLAW CHANGE TO LIMIT THE NUMBER OF REPS ON THE BOARD?
SIMMONS: YES IT WOULD TAKE A BYLAWS CHANGE.
HARWELL: E-BLAST WAY TO GO. BIGLER: AGREE.
SIMMONS: MAP SHOULD BE REVIEWED REGULARLY.
HARWELL: WRITE BYLAWS SO THAT BOARD COULD REDO THE MAP EVERY COUPLE OF YEARS AS NUMBERS CHANGE AS MEMBER PARTICIPATION CHANGES.
SIMMONS: YES THAT SHOULD BE BOARD ACTION. WAYNE, DO YOU HAVE WHAT YOU NEED?
LOHMAN: BY FRIDAY. HARWELL: WE’RE NOT SAYING FRIDAY SINCE IT’S AN E-BLAST, GET IT TO THE BOARD BY FRIDAY. NEXT MEETING PLANNING. NEXT WEEK PROPOSAL TO BOARD.
WEAVER: I’LL HELP IF NECESSARY.
SIMMONS: ANY BOARD MEMBERS WHO BELIEVES ADVANTAGE OR DISADVANTAGE FOR REGIONAL REPRESENTATION SEND TO WAYNE.
Candy Weaver: The rules committee in the last month has fielded rules questions forwarded from the KCBS office.
Recently a copy of the 2014 rules was requested and distributed for the purpose of editing the rules to reinforce positive definitions of barbeque (as defined by USDA section 319.80), how it's cooked with the thought of eliminating prohibitions. Any method not defined is not allowed. This should be presented to the board at the next meeting.
BIGLER: WHAT ABOUT THE IRONMAN CONTEST?
WEAVER: COMMITTEE’S THOUGHTS WERE THAT THIS IS A COMPETITOR SERIES BECAUSE OF THE ORGANIZER’S AMOUNT OF MEAT LIMITATION. SHOULD THE TEAMS OPT INTO THIS AS AN “ADDED” EVENT FOR A SANCTIONED CONTEST, THIS COULD BE DONE BUT NOT AS AN ORGANIZER MANDATE.
COLLIER: RULE 12 “ILLEGAL GARNISH” IN FRONT OF KALE, ENDIVE & RED TIP LETUCE. SEEING MORE DQ THIS YEAR BECAUSE THE PERIOD AFTER CILANTRO IS HARD TO SEE.
COMPTON: DIDN’T WE VOTE TO CHANGE THIS LAST YEAR?
BIGLER: PAMPLET AND WEB SITE DON’T MATCH EITHER. WEAVER: LOTS OF THINGS DON’T MATCH UP ON THE WEB SITE.
COMPTON: THIS WAS CHANGED AFTER THE OPEN RULES MEETING 2 YEARS AGO. COLLIER: MORE DQs THIS YEAR BECAUSE OF THIS.
WEAVER: WE MISSED THIS, KIM’S RIGHT.
Candy Weaver: I move that a judge's contest report detailing their average scores per category, their table's average category scores along with the average scores for the contest be developed and made available on the web site for the judge to download, if desired. 6/11/2014 TABLED PENDING WHAT TECHNOLOGY COMES BACK WITH ON CURRENTLY APPROVED PROPOSALS. 7/9/2014 RE-TABLED FOR THE SAME REASON ABOVE. 8/13 MOVE TO RETABLE THIS MOTION, WAITING FOR BBQSCORECARD.COM HANDLING OF THIS. 2ND BIGLER. PASSED.
Candy Weaver: While at Memphis in May this past spring, Carolyn and I visited with a company out of Colorado that does beautiful work with custom metal trophies (steelimagesinc.com). Please check out samples of their work on their web site. Carolyn has reached out to them and asked for preliminary designs for Team of the Year trophies. The advantage is that these will lay flat for easy packing in a suitcase. I move that we pursue re-designing Team of the Year trophies so that the KCBS logo will feature predominately with graduated size increasing with higher placement. 2ND COMPTON. PASSED.
Candy Weaver: Last year, the board accepted new designs for 180 pins that replace the 180 Star and 180 circle with a KCBS logo based design (designs attached). Because of existing supply of "plain" pins, we have not started using these designs. I move that the current plain 180 pins (star and circle) be retired IN MID-DECEMBER 2014 WITH THE START OF THE 2015 TEAM OF THE YEAR and the new designed pins with the KCBS logo in front of the star and circle be implemented as soon as pins are made, received and disbursed to the rep corps IN MID-DECEMBER. 2ND HARWELL.
BIGLER: CURRENT INVENTORY? WELLS: 177 CIRCLE , 635 STARS, COMBINED VALUE $668.
BIGLER: AS THE REPS TO SEND BACK.
WELLS: DESTROY THEM.
SIMMONS: EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1ST.
COLLER: CAN WE USE PLAIN ONES FOR KIDS QUE?
HARWELL: OKAY WITH ROUND ONES BUT COOKS HOLD THESE STARS CLOSE TO THE HEART, DON’T WANT TO SEE STARS RUNNING AROUND ON KIDS.
POLSON: WAIT TIL WE GET OTHER PINS IN AND DECIDE.
HARWELL: WE’RE NOT GOING TO GET RID OF 600 PINS IN A COUPLE OF MONTHS. WEAVER: ABOUT 4 YEARS WORTH OF PINS.
WEAVER: ADD AT START OF 2015 TEAM OF THE YEAR POINTS.
WELLS: REPS SEND BACK PINS? BIGLER: SEND BACK WITH CONTEST STUFF WHEN IT’S TIME TO START NEW ONES.
BIGLER: SHOW THEM OFF AT THE BANQUET TOO.
for meats. for ancillaries and kids’ que.
Don Harwell: From a letter from the Jack Daniel’s Committee: I am concerned that the Jack Daniel’s Committee has reported to KCBS that three organizers were told by KCBS Reps to make-up a team and to turn in something and “they” (the Reps) would make sure the contest counted.
Why would a Rep make-up a team and why would we (KCBS) allow persons to work for us in this behavior.
I ask (motion) the Rep committee review this behavior and present to the BOD their findings. WITHDRAWN. COLLIER: REP COMMITTEE WILL INVESTIGATE THIS.
And I would like to open back up discussion on “a late turn-in being turned in for “1s” but not being judged at a table”. I motion that late turn-ins be sent to a table to be judged, but the table be told that the entry must receive all 1s for being late. WITHDRAWN
Closed Session AGENDA:
SIMMONS: MEMBER ACTIONS. DISCUSSION OF REPS IN TRAINING BECOMING REPS, CANDIDATES FOR REPS IN TRAINING.
PRESTON: I MOVE THAT WE GO INTO CLOSED SESSION. 2ND BIGLER. PASSED
BIGLER: I MOVE THAT IAN SCHMIDT OF CALIFORNIA BE ACCEPTED AS A REP. 2ND COMPTON. PASSED
BIGLER: I MOVE THAT KEVIN AND MICHELLE ROSE OF GREAT BEND, KANSAS BE ALLOWED TO START REP IN TRAINING. 2ND COMPTON. PASSED.
COLLIER: I MOVE THAT WE GO FORWARD WITH THE CONTRACT WITH BBQSCORECARD.COM SENDING TO THE ATTORNEYS TO WRITE. 2ND WEAVER. PASSED
BIGLER: MOTION TO ADJOURN. 2ND PRESTON. PASSED